Editor’s Note: Sign up for CNN’s Stress, But Less newsletter. Our six-part mindfulness guide will inform and inspire you as you learn how to reduce stress and take advantage of it.
CNN
—
like prince harry problematic relationship accounts With his younger brother Prince William making headlines in his new memoir, Spare, you might wonder if there’s hope in a relationship as difficult as this. Especially if you’re navigating a similar kind of crack.
Although the bond between the brothers was strong, Leading to Greater Health and HappinessSibling estrangement is perhaps more common than splits between parents and adult children. Because of this, there is a greater willingness to repair these relationships.
“For siblings, there are no similar expectations about staying in touch,” said Coleman, the author of the book.The Rules of Alienation: Why Adult Children Break Bonds and How to Heal Conflicts“Siblings do not have role violations that create shame that motivates and drives remediation.”
While estrangement or end of a relationship with a sibling can still feel difficult or shameful, people who initiate the estrangement find it beneficial, Coleman says.
“Assuming they exercise due diligence and the (other) sibling is unable or unwilling to modify or change their behavior, severing the relationship may be better for their mental health than continuing. I don’t think so,” Coleman said.
In case it’s not so clear, Coleman offers some pointers for knowing when a relationship is worth saving and when it’s better to cut it.
This conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity.
CNN: What are the most common triggers for sibling estrangement?
Coleman: Typical reasons for the onset of sibling rivalry and estrangement include perceived or objectively discriminatory treatment by parents. A history of emotional, physical, or sexual abuse by a sibling can be traumatic, especially if they haven’t made amends or if the hurt sibling has been unable to forgive. Relationships can also be triggered by one being jealous or intimidated by the other’s success, which can drive a wedge.
Sometimes it starts with siblings moving away from their parents, but if other siblings aren’t allied with them or are critical of their estrangement, it’s better to say, “Well, you agree or disagree with me.” It can evoke emotions.
CNN: What’s your first step when faced with recurring conflicts?
Coleman: You are about relationships in that you have to give people the chance to repair and communicate your needs in a way that really invites introspection and empathy on their part, rather than being hurtful or defensive. You have to be very careful.
A sibling’s actions may hurt, embarrass, humiliate, criticize, or disparage. So I said, “This has to change if you want to continue with me. I think it makes a lot of sense what you’re asking me to do, and I really hope you change the way you communicate.” But if this is not something you can fix, I’m starting to feel that I’ll probably need to keep out of contact with you for quite some time.
Indeed, an abuser is out of control and requires strong limits to counteract their behavior. That doesn’t mean they should never be given the chance to mend or reconcile, but only after they show their willingness to commit to making amends and changing.
CNN: When is it worth repairing a relationship?
Coleman: When estranged siblings seek reconciliation, one is usually more motivated than the other to heal it, and so takes a more leadership role in mending the dynamic.
If the other person is showing genuine empathy, is not defensive, is committed to change, and is willing to respect the boundaries and requirements of a healthy relationship, they are likely to have a healthy relationship that needs repair. It’s an important factor.
CNN: When is the best time to cut your tie?
Coleman: I really struggle with that question because I feel our culture is too supportive and too quick to cut ties.
A certain amount of self-reflection is necessary when someone is thinking about something very important. Who are you sensitive to? Are you constantly ghosting people in every aspect of your life? Are you accusing everyone of gaslighting you if you disagree with your perception of events? Do you just cut the other one off because you can’t tolerate conflict?
If you feel so preoccupied with them that you can’t separate your identity from what triggered them, it may be helpful to take a break from the relationship. For some people, a period of distance that isn’t constantly triggered or reminded about things they don’t like or are upsetting about themselves can help.
Assuming you’ve completed all other steps of due diligence, a break in contact for a while might be a good wake-up call for the sibling.
CNN: How long should the grace period or trial period be?
Coleman: With new boundaries, no one can be 100% perfect. The goal is to agree that new dynamics will be tackled together. Perhaps it’s because people who engage in harmful behaviors are unaware of it, or they need to be educated on an ongoing basis.
Keep the dialogue going and keep the dialogue going for at least a few months. You might say But when you start defending Mom and Dad against me or competing with me on anything, I get triggered and upset.
CNN: How do I distance myself from or end a relationship?
Coleman: Say: And you feel like you can’t do it or are so unmotivated that it reduces my desire to spend time with you. And we can let you know if or when that will change. ”
CNN: What do people tend to experience after changing or breaking a sibling relationship and how can they cope?
Coleman: People who end relationships usually feel less pain than those who break up. People who get things done may feel relieved and happy.
However, not all is always good. Ending a relationship means not only losing contact with the parts of us that we don’t like, but also losing contact with the parts that we like. There may be a sense of loss or sadness about recognizing or realizing things that may not exist.
They may also feel embarrassed or guilty when other family members get mad at them or pressure them to get back in touch.
Remember the effort you put in. If you’re ashamed of your decisions, you’re only adding insult to injury. You gave the person a reasonable period of time to give them your full attention, so this is not something you did in a capricious or selfish way.
CNN: What if being estranged causes problems with other family members?
Coleman: Empathize with their pain, stating firmly that you worked hard to make your siblings react differently to you, but they didn’t want or couldn’t. You can’t maintain a relationship with your siblings just because your parents want them to.