The first time the internet saw DCU Superman star Henry Cavill play Geralt of Rivia in the Netflix adaptation. witcherthat barked with group laughter Over a terrible wig. Four years later, fans are swooning over Hollywood’s major himbo Won’t reprise the role after Season 3 endsOne obvious explanation for why is that Cavill has signed a deal to shoot a new piece. Superman But fans believe the real reason Cavill is leaving is that he’s tired of fighting Netflix. witcher Faithful to its literary source material.
Surprising news of Cavill’s impending departure was shared yesterday in a statement By Netflix, also announced by Liam Hemsworth hunger game Fame will take over that role in season four. I pass the torch with enthusiasm for”.
While many were disappointed man from uncle won’t get caught anymore Roaring “Cockroach” With horses of the coming season, witcher Fans took the news particularly badly.Books, Games, and Netflix Series Subreddits Explode distrust, FrustrationWhen memewhile the conspiracy theory got I went around on Twitter Cavill had been more or less kicked out over creative differences with the work that sometimes gave liberal liberties to Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski’s original novel. witcher fandom always had Toxic relationship with Shawhas been outraged about certain casting choices and plot deviations, and Cavill’s departure is currently being taken as a validation of all the criticism it’s received thus far.
To support their theory, fans breadcrumb trail Quoting from a previous interview by Cavill on his desire to keep Netflix’s Geralt true to what he first put on paper in the pages of a fantasy magazine Fantastica Way back in 1986, less than a year later, the actor said he said hollywood reporter He was “absolutely” committed to the show’s seven-season plan. [author Andrzej] Sapowski’s work. ”
During the media tour around season two’s release last year, Cavill spoke repeat In addition to the savage monster slayer, he is smart, thoughtful, and “amateur philosopher“This season, I wanted to more accurately represent the original Geralt and see him speak more,” he said. total film at the time. “I pushed really, really hard for that.”
Then, showrunner Lauren Hissrich himself commented on Cavill’s preparations for season 2. Tell me more,” she said. Said hollywood reporter“Everyone came out of season 1 laughing and loving Geralt’s fuming. But Henry said that when he reads a book, he spends a lot of time in Geralt’s head. So what do we do?” Can you put that on the page?’ What about Cavill’s aspirations for the future of the series? or have side effects that make the water cloudy,” he said. Netflix Geek Conversation last year.who poured oil on the fire A recent interview with Beau DeMayoformer producer witcher man running now X-Men ’97 On Disney+, some writers “actively disliked” and even “ridiculed” the source material.
What some fans got out of these soundbites was that Hissrich was focused on making the show what she wanted, whereas only Cavill was grounded in the original version of the character. This happens in the context of a long Reddit thread in this way Fans have detailed all the ways Season 2 differs from the books, and Season 3, which doesn’t air until the summer of 2023, could include an even bigger departure.
The theory is compelling when folded into a few viral tweets, but the show’s place within the larger fandom has always been more complicated than that. Hissrich was temporarily kicked off Twitter before Season 1’s release when he petitioned let only white women She plays the lead role of Ciri, the adopted daughter of Geralt. Then there were those on the edge of the fandom who had no knowledge or interest in the Grimdark Fantasy series until Netflix spent tens of millions of dollars to make it happen. hurting the experience of I have written One user joined the show’s subreddit last year.Then there are CD Projekt Red’s fans. witcher video game trilogy It took great liberties with its storytelling, effectively creating its own parallel lore.
Whether or not Cavill was a purist on set is largely out of the question.His role in Season 2 clearly did little to prevent some of the narrative departures that fans had the most trouble with. It was glue. The fact that I like PC games and drawing warhammer miniature In his free time he was clearly a big fan of Sapkowski’s books and even the worst stalwarts gave him huge street cred witcher fan. That’s not because he’s a pedant when it comes to lore, but because he’s a charismatic being who ultimately manages to combine kindness, ruthlessness, and morbid wit into something deeper than he is. halloween ghost costumes proposed first. “I think it was Henry Cavill’s Geralt who tied it all together.” Kotaku Senior Critic Harper Jay said in a VG chat in 2018 About the first season.
Now that the glue is gone, witcher Season 4 has its work cut short with Cavill dogging it every single time. Whether Hemsworth gets the job done or not, news has already wrapped at least season 3. Fans will get one last chance to return to that world with Cavill as their anchor. I’m sure it will all work out. more conspiratorial speculation About creative differences.